Contributed by: masodo on Wednesday, December 19 2012 @ 09:36 am UTC
Last modified on
http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/12/19/167610327/eagle-snatches-kid-video-the-debunking-begins
Three students studying animation and digital design at Montreal's Centre NAD, the school says, made a video that's gone viral today because it looks (sort of) like an eagle snatched a baby off the ground and started to fly away with the little kid.
But Centre NAD "reassures Montrealers" that there's "no danger of being snatched by a royal eagle." The video was a digitized class project, not a real snatching.
It IDs the clever students as Normand Archambault, Loïc Mireault and Félix Marquis-Poulin.
But wait, could this admission just be a trick? Anybody up for some digital analysis of the school's press release[*3] ?
Probably not: According to the school, its students have fooled some folks before, with a "Penguin escaped zoo in Montreal!!![*4] " video.
Pretty real looking, eh?
Our original post — " 'Eagle Snatches Kid' Video: The Debunking Begins":
Here's a distraction from the day's heavier news:
It may be a fake — and many on the Web are saying just that. But it's for real that the "Golden Eagle Snatches Kid" video[*5] of something that supposedly happened in Montreal is going viral this morning.
The team at StoryfulPro[*6] has collected some of the debunking that's going on. There's work being done on Reddit[*7] , for instance on the sudden appearance of the bird's shadow[*8] . On Twitter, "@thornae[*9] " has been posting about things such as "the disappearing wing[*10] ."
The Montreal Gazette, meanwhile, says that[*11] "on CBC Radio Thursday morning, bird expert David Bird called the incident a hoax, pointing out that it's an image of an osprey, not an eagle, as the video states."
Two-Way readers who sideline in digital forensics are welcome to offer their analyses in the comments thread.
Update at 11 a.m. ET. More Analysis:
Check this video from AnimalWire[*12] .
And, yes, we (like many other news outlets) have a message in to the video's creator. If we get in touch we'll update with what we find out.
[tag:video strange youtube hoax humor living]